Tuned RF Level Measurement Poll

Started by BigPMELDude, 04-15-2009 -- 19:18:00

Previous topic - Next topic

What would you rather use for Tuned RF Level Measurements?

MMR
5 (19.2%)
8902MS
19 (73.1%)
1295
0 (0%)
Other
2 (7.7%)

Total Members Voted: 26

mdbuike

Quote from: flew-da-coup on 05-16-2009 -- 13:40:37
We need to also mention that the MMR takes longer to measure AM/FM Mod. at least that is my experience. 8902 takes a much faster reading.

Have you looked at the cal procedure for the MMR?  How do they ceritify the AM/FM calibration?  Implied?

Maybe an old argument..but I'll use the 8902A

Mike
Summum ius summa iniuria.

The more law, the less justice.

Cicero, De Officiis, I, 33

Duckbutta

Agilent claims that if the Tuned RF Level and Spectrum Analyzer portions of the instrument pass, all other parameters are "guaranteed by design". This makes sense to a certain degree being as though you can measure modulation depths (AM) and rates (FM) on a spectrum analyzer. I'm assuming that the instrument uses the spectrum analyzer circuitry (amplitude and frequency markers, span, etc.) to compute the modulation and convert it to a easy-to-read numerical display via the Measuring Receiver Personality option.

BigPMELDude

Quote from: mdbuike link=topic=1266. msg13216#msg13216 date=1242530724
Have you looked at the cal procedure for the MMR?  How do they ceritify the AM/FM calibration?  Implied?

Maybe an old argument. . but I'll use the 8902A

Mike


I have been trying to get AFMETCAL to tell me how AM/FM and even TRFL measurements are made.  No such luck.  They can't tell me what specifications guide is the correct one.  Been told June 2008, even the lovely spreadsheet they made.  So VERY frustrating.

Bryan

Whats a MMR?  Who makes it.
I've got a Rhode & Schwarz FSMR with sensor head-it's very fast in tuned RF compared to the 8902A.  The part that impresses me during verification vs. the 8902A is that an arbitrary waveform generator is used to make actual AM & FM signals of a known level, the 8902A seems like it's all relative measurements.
It's furfigtestin!

flew-da-coup

Quote from: Bryan on 05-28-2009 -- 16:24:39
Whats a MMR?  Who makes it.
I've got a Rhode & Schwarz FSMR with sensor head-it's very fast in tuned RF compared to the 8902A.  The part that impresses me during verification vs. the 8902A is that an arbitrary waveform generator is used to make actual AM & FM signals of a known level, the 8902A seems like it's all relative measurements.
It's furfigtestin!

Its a fancy spec an that replaces the 8902A ( or supposed to ).
You shall do no injustice in judgment, in measurement of length, weight, or volume.Leviticus 19:35